1. Home
  2. Knowledge Base
  3. Scientific Studies
  4. Behavior
  5. Dog
  6. Dominance in Domestic Dogs Revisited: Useful Habit and Useful Construct?
  1. Home
  2. Knowledge Base
  3. Scientific Studies
  4. Behavior
  5. Dominance in Domestic Dogs Revisited: Useful Habit and Useful Construct?
  1. Home
  2. Knowledge Base
  3. Scientific Studies
  4. Behavior
  5. Dominance
  6. Dominance in Domestic Dogs Revisited: Useful Habit and Useful Construct?

Dominance in Domestic Dogs Revisited: Useful Habit and Useful Construct?

Matthijs B.H. Schilder, Claudia M. Vinke, Joanne A.M. van der Borg 2014

ABSTRACT

In the last decade, the validity and relevance of the dominance model was regularly put into question regarding relationships between canids like dogs and wolves, and consequently, human-dog relationships as well. The concept underlying this model, scientifically defined as an intervening variable reflecting status difference between individuals, is applicable when formal status signals symbolize the long-term relationship between individuals, resulting in a formalized dominance hierarchy. This article reviews the basics underlying the concept of dominance and reflects on the value and importance of some new quantitative studies on the applicability of the concept of dominance in domestic dogs. The conclusions are, first, that formal dominance is present in the domestic dog, expressed by context-independent unidirectional formal status signals. Consequently, formal dominance (e.g., submission) plays an important role in assessing status in dog-dog relationships. Second, that nonverbal status-related communication in humans resembles that in dogs to a considerable degree, and hence dogs may be well able to interpret this human status-related nonverbal communication from their perspective. Dominance is therefore also likely to play a role in human-dog relationships. Hence, the dominance concept might be useful to explain the development of certain problems in dog-dog and dog-human relationships. However, enforcing a dominant status by a human may entail considerable risks and should therefore be avoided.

Download full study below

Article Attachments

Related Articles

Responses

Recently Active Members

Profile photo of Adrian Rykaczewski
0
Profile photo of Alex Bornemann
15
Profile photo of Jeff Thomson
0
Profile photo of VASCO GREVESMÜHL
0
Profile photo of Philip Koblischek
0
Profile photo of Shoko
8
Profile photo of Katrina Perillo Perillo
0
Profile photo of Allie McCain
215
Profile photo of Michael D'Abruzzo
954
Profile photo of Cyndi Cross
5
Profile photo of Jose Chavez
0
Profile photo of Arthur Lopatin
222
Profile photo of Taylor Bagwell
34
Profile photo of Judy
276
Profile photo of Taira Palacios
0
Profile photo of Themis
0
Profile photo of Dave Page
360
Profile photo of Kimberly Cunningham
0
Profile photo of Jared Mc Intyre
4
Profile photo of Donald Hutcherson
0
Profile photo of Dustin
23
Profile photo of Jens Lundberg
0
Profile photo of Brad Rimmel
0
Profile photo of Shell Kaminsky
0
Profile photo of Josh Young
11
Profile photo of Cara Ruth Ruth
6
Profile photo of Guido Rossi
8
Profile photo of leroy williams
4