Understanding the difference between extrinsic and intrinsic motivation in dog training can help you effectively train and bond with your dog by tapping into what motivates them most effectively. Each type has its place in training, and often the best approach combines both forms of motivation.
Extrinsic Motivation:
Extrinsic motivation refers to behavior driven by external rewards. In dog training, these rewards can be anything from treats, praise, toys, or playtime that the dog receives from an external source (usually the owner or trainer) for performing a desired behavior.
- Examples:
- Treats: Giving a dog a treat for sitting, staying, or coming when called.
- Praise and Affection: Offering verbal praise like "Good boy!" or "Good girl!" when a dog performs correctly, especially when paired with physical affection.
- Play: Engaging in a favorite game, like fetch or tug-of-war, after the dog follows a command.
- Applications: Extrinsic motivators are particularly useful in the early stages of learning a new behavior to clearly communicate to the dog what is desired. It can also be very effective in reinforcement schedules where rewards are given intermittently to maintain an established behavior.
Intrinsic Motivation:
Intrinsic motivation involves behaviors driven by internal satisfaction or fulfillment rather than external rewards. This type of motivation is about what feels innately rewarding to the dog, without any visible rewards from the outside.
- Examples:
- Problem-Solving: Some dogs enjoy the challenge of solving puzzles, like treat-dispensing toys, which provide mental stimulation.
- Chewing and Dissecting: Chewing or tearing objects apart, is innately satisfying to most dogs.
- Herding, Hunting, or Chasing: Breeds with strong working or hunting instincts might be intrinsically motivated to engage in activities like herding sheep, scent work, or chasing balls, fulfilling their natural drives and instincts.
- Applications: Harnessing a dog's intrinsic motivations can lead to highly reliable behaviors because the activity itself is rewarding. Training that aligns with a dog’s natural inclinations and fulfills their instinctual needs can be exceptionally gratifying and reinforcing without external rewards.
Combining Extrinsic and Intrinsic Motivation:
Successful dog training often involves a mix of both extrinsic and intrinsic motivation. For example, teaching a retriever to fetch might start with treat rewards (extrinsic) but gradually the joy of retrieving (intrinsic) becomes the primary reward.
Benefits of Each Type:
- Extrinsic Motivation:
- Easy to implement and control.
- Helps establish the foundation of basic obedience and complex skills.
- Can be adjusted according to the dog’s preferences and what works best in various training contexts.
- Intrinsic Motivation:
- Leads to self-reinforcing behavior.
- Encourages longer-term engagement and satisfaction in the activity.
- Reduces the reliance on external rewards, making the behavior more durable in different environments.
Understanding these motivations can help you create a more effective and enjoyable training experience for your dog, enhancing both their learning and their quality of life. It’s important to observe and learn what naturally interests and motivates your dog, and use that understanding to guide your training methods.
I love this! This is so important to think about technically and I often glaze over it! Thank you for the reminder!
You need to login in order to like this post: click here